Tippett Studio 谈《曼达洛人与古古》定格动画机器人守卫制作
Stop-motion delights
Tippett Studio 为《曼达洛人与古古》制作了 Hutt 宫殿机器人守卫的定格动画段落,共 36 个镜头、约两分钟,两个三臂多活动部件的角色耗时近一年拍摄。
The making of stop-motion animated Arges and Bullethead by Tippett Studio, including some Star Wars-related Easter eggs to look out for. An excerpt from issue #68 of the magazine.
In Star Wars history, Phil Tippett is a key player in the creation of so many pivotal characters, vehicles and sequences, especially in terms of stop-motion and puppet work. Memorable Tippett moments relate to the Dejarik holochess game, Tauntauns, walkers and the Rancor. His Tippett Studio has, in more recent times, been brought on board the Star Wars streaming series to contribute stop-motion animation (for the Trash Walkers in The Mandalorian series, B’omarr monks in The Book of Boba Fett and Mama Crab in Skeleton Crew). For The Mandalorian and Grogu, Tippett Studio realized the robotic Hutt Palace guards.
“We knew in pre-production we wanted to do a sequence with Tippett,” shares Knoll. “The thing that stood out to me as relatively contained that was a really good choice was the Mando and Grogu fight with those droids. It’s about two minutes long. It’s 36 shots. So it was kind of on the ambitious end, with two fairly complex characters. They’re multi-limbed. Each one of them has three arms and they have all these moving pieces on them; moving parts on their heads, moving armor plates, and this moving skirt. In fact, the Tippett guys said it was the most complicated thing that they’ve ever done, and it took a better part of a year to shoot.”

“Part of Jon Favreau’s feeling is that stop-motion has a charm to it,” adds Knoll. “It’s okay that you can tell it’s stop-motion, in the same way that it’s okay you’re looking at a puppet or a guy in a rubber mask. That’s always been part of Star Wars and part of the suspension of disbelief and what people like about them.”
The clear ‘look and feel’ of classic staccato stop-motion animation is all throughout the droid fight, but motion blur was added to the final shots. “The live-action with Mando running around has motion blur,” notes Knoll. “And when the camera pans, there’s motion blur in that. We didn’t want to have completely crisp still frames. So, we’d do an optical flow-based motion blur over the top of the stop-motion to try and get it to be this hybrid aesthetic that’s partly between Harryhausen back in the day, and what you see in computer graphics, that is, somewhere in that spectrum where the motion blur isn’t all technically accurate. There’s places where it’s a little clipped or isn’t exactly right, but it’s not quite as jarring of an aesthetic difference as the old Harryhausen stuff is.”
Tippett Studio was engaged early to help figure out what some of the fun gags could be featuring the droid guards. “We started by basically asking Phil to dream up stuff, to just give us his thoughts,” recalls Hickel. “He went away for a little bit, came back some point later and had some rough boards he’d done. They had cut them together with some music just so he could pitch them to Jon Favreau. It then became a combination of what was in the script, Phil’s ideas, and other storyboards by Dave Lowery. We would effectively have little story meetings. It would be me and the editors and John Knoll and Jon Favreau and his writing partner Noah Kloor, as well as Doug Chiang and the whole brains trust down in LA. We would talk through the sequence and the ideas and work it out.”

Early CG previs and rough animation was also explored. “We were trying desperately to avoid having to do retakes on things that were this complicated,” suggests Knoll. “We wanted to make sure that everybody was buying into the shot designs and the timings and that the storytelling was all working for everybody, so that when it came time to do these tremendously labor-intensive animations, that, to the largest extent possible, we were only doing a single take on each one.”
At Tippett Studio, individual artists took on multiple roles for the stop-motion guards, from fabrication to animation and photography. “This work is definitely an extension of what we’ve been doing already,” mentions Tippett Studio visual effects supervisor Ken Rogerson. “Every show in the Star Wars franchise is just a little more elaborate than the last.”
After the ideation process with Phil Tippett, artists at the studio continued to work with Doug Chiang on droid designs. “Doug wanted us to go back and forth a little bit with their art department to build out the droids,” establishes Tippett Studio visual effects supervisor Mark Dubeau. “They came to us kind of bare bones with not a lot of detailing on the designs. We had an opportunity to not only add more detail, but we had to modify them as we were building them so that they actually worked with the stop-motion armature inside. It was a good thing that they hadn’t gone too far with them because there might’ve been a bunch of detail we would’ve had to eradicate while we were figuring out how to fit the armature inside and all of that.”

This early stage also involved continual back and forth with the filmmakers. Tippett Studio then crafted its own CG versions of the droids. “Ultimately,” explains Hickel, “they were going to do a lot of 3D printing for all the super complicated parts. So they built full CG versions of these droids and rigged them to be animated in Maya. They had all the detail, but on layers it had the planned armature and how all the pieces fit and everything.”
That process continued into Tippett Studio previs’ing the sequence itself. “They had done this with the Mama Crab where they pre-animated in CG so that folks could buy off on speed and timing and choreography before they dove into the hard work,” says Hickel. “It was a lengthy process of them generating CG previs in Maya. I would also be generating previs. Tippett gave me their CG assets, and I was cooking up shots and ideas in my spare time. I’d cut stuff together, I’d hand stuff to our editor Dylan, the editor, he’d cut stuff. We’d show it to Jon Favreau, he’d have a bunch of notes and we’d do that cycle over. We did it over and over and over again ahead of shooting that scene until we finally got to a sequence where we could all say, ‘Yeah, this is what it is.’”
Tippett Studio visual effects supervisor Tom ‘Gibby’ Gibbons reiterates why that long previs process was necessary. “The way that the schedule works, it’s very different in visual effects than it is in an actual animated film. We have to establish what everything is and what they do before we ever get to the stage and to shooting them. We’ve been super lucky with the Star Wars series that all the directors seem to really get it and they don’t fight it and they don’t push back and get annoyed. It’s like they look at this as part of the, ‘Yeah, we’re figuring this out and as we go,’ and it works out really great that way.”

Once the previs had been agreed upon, live-action for the fight was filmed (second unit director Peter Ramsey directed the sequence). “They went onto a soundstage and shot Mando against a bluescreen,” states Rogerson, “knowing what the action was and where his eyeline would be and how far he had to run in every shot so they could get plates that then would interact with the robots when we went back and shot those stop-motion.”
The next step was puppet fabrication of the two droids, which ended up being dubbed Bullethead and Argus (more on why, later). One of Tippett Studio’s challenges in the build related to the robot nature of the droids, made up of more than 60 individual pieces each. “All the pieces that were eventually kit bashed together had to be created into something that could be solidly printed and then interact with each other,” details Tippett Studio lead fabricator John ‘JD’ Daniel. “These were hard surfaces, these weren’t soft puppets. Again, that’s why having that previs was essential because we needed to know things like, is the droid going to be reaching very far above his head? If that’s the case, where’s that shoulder going to go, and how does that all interact? Every single piece of these droids becomes a small engineering project to make sure that it fits on the armature that we’re designing while the animation is being figured out.”
Tippett Studio’s Brett Foxwell custom-built a steel armature, some of which deliberately shows through the droids outer shell. “You can actually see a lot of the actual real metal of the armature in there, which was really fun to do for this droid,” states Daniel. “Other parts were made to look like an armature, but it’s really 3D printed resin. There’s also a whole lot of parts that were done with the traditional process of mold making and casting.”

The droids were ultimately made out of a number of materials: steel, resin, silicone, urethane, wire and even rubber bands. “You name it, everything came into play,” shares Dubeau. “John Favreau was really picky about the paint scheme on these things, too. He had a lot of rules in terms of the colors that could be beside each other. If we had the wrong green and red next to each other, he would just go, ‘Boba Fett! That looks like Boba Fett. So I’d have to completely repaint it and make it a different color.”
The droids were designed to feature skirts. “Originally they had skirts that were cloth,” mentions Dubeau. “We were banging our heads trying to figure out, okay, well, how can we do this? Gibby actually has experience animating a cloth and he suggested putting these pieces of flexible material behind the skirts.”
“Yes,” adds Daniel, “Gibby made these little pieces of styrene to look like rusted metal. And in the end, we came up with these neat metal chimes like plates hanging down. At first we tried wire attachments, but wire has a ‘memory’ which turned out to inhibit really granular movement where one blade would touch another. So we opted for each of them having a ball and socket.”

“They were a nightmare to make,” reveals Gibbons, “but what was really funny is they weren’t as much of a nightmare as they looked like because there was a rhythm to them that it was almost comforting compared to the rest of them because once I started animating shots, I could just move one and then every other one cascaded behind it. It just turns into this rhythm when you’re doing the shot. The only time that it got messy was when a leg would move forward or they’d twist and all of a sudden, the plates would pinch and you’d have to predict that before you got there so you could start trying to move them behind each other or in front of each other so they’d stack instead of collide.”
In fact, Dubeau admits that Tippett Studio “tried for a little bit to convince John Knoll and his team to take on those plates as a digital element, but I think that we did the right thing. I know that people wanted to be able to point at it and go, ‘That’s all stop-motion.’ The only thing that’s not stop-motion coming out of them is really their laser blasts and a hand grenade. Everything else is pretty much in-camera.”
The in-camera nature of the fight included almost everything seen behind the droids, with the environment in which they were animated being a miniature set that had to match the full-scale live-action one. “The environment was a big undertaking,” discusses Dubeau. “In the Hutt Palace, you’re basically going through mycelium, you’re in a giant spore. The idea is that these are all bubbles inside of oxygen or whatever it is that gets caught in there and they’ve essentially drilled through them. So that’s why everything was incredibly curved and linear and almost perfect. That was actually very challenging to get these super clean and pleasing shapes because initially, we were looking at it and it’s like, oh, it’s like a cave. And when we got the concept art for it and the lines were so clean, I thought that it would end up rough-looking, but it didn’t.”

“We had to explain to the miniature set builders, ‘It’s like going in with a giant melon baller and just scooping these perfect circles out,’” continues Dubeau. “I remember walking onto the stage and Kayte Sabicer and Bill Boes were in there and they were just sanding these very sweeping arcs to get those perfect round things. Just the looks on their faceS because it goes against what you really want to do. You want to make things really rough. But of course it looked great on screen and it really matched what they had done on set.”
The doors in front of which the droids stand guard brought their own set of complications. The original idea was that they were doors to the Hutt throne room, and so were built very clean. “We made these beautiful bronze, gold and silver doors,” explains Dubeau. “There was a little tarnish to them and then Jon Favreau saw them and said, ‘No, I want to see rust and all this stuff.’ I would be just sitting there for day after day after day, just adding more rust, putting it on set, taking a picture, sending it to him and he’s like, ‘No, more, more.’ But that’s the fun part. You always want to hear ‘more, more’ because the moment they start saying, ‘Oh, less, less,’ it’s really hard to take stuff away.”
The choice to animate the droids in a set rather than against a greenscreen, say, was driven by the desired end look, according to Rogerson. “Especially because this is a very much a pools of light kind of environment and a lot of interactive light when the explosions are going off, especially with any reflective surfaces on the robot. If you shoot it on greenscreen, you’re always going to be fighting that comp look. If you’re really careful about how you light things, you can get there, but by doing it the way we did it, you’re going to get it so much faster and you’re going to get so much more detail.”

“One of the things that you always find with environments is that if you want a nice, beautiful cityscape of a futuristic city with clean glass, you can do that in a computer,” adds Rogerson. “But if you want a grungy, damp, dirty cave, it’s going to be faster to do that by throwing dirt on a wall and gluing some roots to plaster. You’re going to get so much more detail and realism out of that. Especially if you’re working with people that have experience with miniatures. It’s going to have the right scale and it’s just going to look fantastic and you don’t have to question whether you’ve done the right thing to make it look real because it is real. For example, we might paint things with shellac to get that puddle of water look and make everything look damp. It certainly was a lot of work to build that set. Obviously, we were on it for months, but man-hours wise, to do that as a digital environment would’ve probably been more and then would’ve had that digital curse to it that you never quite get around.”
“The reason it goes faster in the real world is you get your detritus for free,” suggests Gibbons. “You get the dust you can’t get out of the nooks and crannies, the sawdust, just the grime that becomes part of the world because you literally couldn’t scrub it out if you wanted to. And that’s the 10% that in a CG world, it’s actually really hard to do convincingly without making it look very artificially placed or repetitively made through some scatter system.”
The miniature set was lit with the aid of cucoloris boards, also known as kooks. Explains Gibbons: “It’s a very small pattern of sticks or tape and you put it in front of a light. This is the thing that we get in the real world. I’ve seen people try to do this digitally and it’s really hard and takes a lot of smart people working on CG lights, noise patterns or shader responses, or interference channels, and I’m not convinced it always works. In stop-motion you can use some ‘toothpicks, tape and hot glue’ and you get the same thing. But as the characters just move gently even through light like that, it breaks their spec patterns up. It just creates this slight fade undulation in highlights. A lot of modulation that’s super granular, almost like you wouldn’t see it. You’d have to stare at it to see it, but if it wasn’t there, that’s what makes things look like plastic and not like a real thing. All those sorts of tricks that we know about in each one of our little eccentric little arts are the reason why this stuff will end up looking real. It looks like stop-motion, but it looks real.”

Adds Gibbons: “Here is a fun factoid. One of the reasons our small band works so well together, I have always used kooks, but it was Ken who really explained why we do them, because he was putting kook designs on bounce cards and I was like, ‘Come on, man, we gotta get this shot launched,’ and he explained fully why he was, so I learned something new and didn’t ever bug him again about putting interference kooks anywhere he wanted them.”
Painting the droids required special attention to detail, notes Dubeau. “If you paint something to be silvery and then you put it on film, depending on the lights, it can wind up just looking gray. Doug Chiang wanted to feel like there were a lot of high kicks off the metal. Now, there’s not that much real metal on it. So what I had to do is figure out the right kind of paints, especially at that scale, for things to come to life. You almost have to paint everything with chrome paint so that you get those pings. The risk is that it can make it look really, really big because it’ll get a sharp, hot little ping. And as he’s moving through these cucoloris lights, the sheen on it, it’ll dance and you’ll get that. It’ll trick your eye into thinking it’s this really big thing.”
The puppets were rigged with internal lights, handled by Tippett Studio stage manager Blair Mendel. Says Rogerson: “Blair wired up all of the LEDs and figured out how to balance the brightness of all those and make the wires disappear. He also built all of the rigs for the interactive lighting because every time they shoot their gun or an explosion goes off, then there’s an interactive light pass that we’ve shot so that they cast their shadow on the wall behind them and each other.”

The droids were constantly being touched up during the stop-motion shoot. “I would fully paint them, put them on stage and within about three, four shots we’re having to take it off-stage and then I’m going in and doing touch-ups again,” recounts Dubeau. “Every shot I would have to go in with my little triage kit. They’re really manhandling these things so paint is going to rub off. As much as I would love them to animate wearing gloves, it’s just not practical. Also, any time I’d see a bag of popcorn on the set, I’d throw it in the garbage. I’d say, ‘No salt, no salt.’ It attacks the paint like crazy.”
Daniel was called in only a few times for fixes. “There were actually a few times where something was either about to break or had broken in a shot and there was some in-between frame surgery that had to happen, but it was very rare,” he says.
Animation of the droids was handled primarily by Gibbons and Chuck Duke, with David Lauer and Ri Crawford also contributing. The large loose-jointed builds of the puppets suited the desired motion, being deliberately mechanical and jittery. Gibbons gave the larger of the droids somewhat of a ‘Frankenstein’ motion by leaning him forward—a suggestion from Phil Tippett—as he worked on walk cycles.


The area was tight to animate in. “We only had one of each puppet,” remarks Gibbons. “So while they were on-screen together, there could only be one animator because animating on a set that’s a cave, you can’t get two animators in there, and you can only get one guy in there at a time. So, that was just me animating all the shots where they’re together. Then as soon as we could cut that set in half, we could use the second animator which was Chuck, who is amazing.”
Hickel, who had previously been a stop-motion animator at Will Vinton Studios, lent his services to animate a shot, too—“It was the easiest shot in the sequence!” Hickel offers (the shot involved one of the droids coming to life with its ‘eye’ spinning around and lighting up). Gibbons remarks, “On every show, I think I’ve said to Hal, ‘You’ve got to come shoot a shot.’ And he’s like, ‘Well, I don’t know, I don’t know.’ And he finally came in for this one and I was so excited because Hal’s no slouch either. He’s really good. So, to get him to come down and just touch a puppet again was so great. Chuck and Hal have known each other since Will Vinton days.”
At this animation stage, one issue the team came up against was that the puppets did not hold themselves up without a supporting rig. There were other challenges, too, as Gibbons outlines. “One of the things that we all learned scientifically, or at least I did, is that the difference between static friction and kinetic friction is very different. Even when you’ve got characters like this, when you want to start moving them after they’ve sat there having their frame taken, the static friction is so strong to overcome, you basically have to just lean into it to get them moving, but it would push them way past the tiny increment you wanted so then you were pulling them back and then pushing them forward and so on and so on until they magically land where you wanted them in the first place.”
“I started to call it ‘shake animation’,” continues Gibbons, “because once the static friction was overcome I’d just sit there and shake the puppet trying to let it not seize up again until I got it where I wanted, almost like with a baseball bat. Well, that wasn’t going to work for the show. So, Ken and I came up with different kinds of character rigs that we could use and sneak into the scene. Brett Foxwell came up a fantastic system of handles and rig ports we could access depending on where the camera was. We could shove them into the back of the droids to help hold them up and then I could loosen the armature just enough that the static friction wasn’t as much of a problem.”
“Beyond that,” says Gibbons, “I had some helper rigs, one in particular called a machinist jack. They’re super precise and very strong and I would use those and then I would use wood blocks/shims. I’m still dying for somebody watching the film to go, ‘Is that wood underneath their feet?’ Because as they take a step I literally would stack wood underneath their feet so that as they take a step forward, the foot would rise and fall, and they’d still be standing on a ground plane, and then I would start pulling it out. We also came up with these ‘don’t touch them’ handles that I would put into the top and into the bottoms so that I could move the whole body without touching the body. And then once I got it to where I wanted, I’d pull those handles out and then I could manipulate elbows, legs, little bits and pieces. These were the most difficult puppets I’ve ever had to control.”
Interestingly, the Tippett Studio team found they were initially nervous at having their work be seen on large cinema screens, including IMAX. “We just really wanted to make sure that it was going to look good,” remembers Daniel. “We actually asked ILM if we could play a couple of tests of our work in one of their big screening rooms. And so they invited us up and we got to go and take a look and it was really satisfying to be able to be like, ‘Oh yeah, we can do this.’”
View this post on Instagram
“That was a good moment,” notes Dubeau, “because everybody went to that room, I think, a little bit sheepishly. Because even when we were detailing it, I was putting some stuff in there, we’d print it out and I’d look at it and I’d be like, ‘Oh, that’s not detailed enough. I need to go further.’ I would put these little screws in the model and then when the thing printed out, they’re not even a millimeter in diameter. They’re these tiny little things. But then when I look at them on the screen, they’re like the size of Oreo cookies. They’re really, really big!”
“I always had faith in what we were doing,” laughs Rogerson. “The beauty of doing things for real is that you get that infinite detail. This is something we’ve all learned from Phil Tippett. He’s the master of this: rust it up, spray acid on it, glue on a bunch of dirt, and then shoot it dark and you can get away with just absolute murder and you get this sense that there’s a real object there without having to put a lot of thought and effort into it.”
The names Bullethead and Arges for the droids were dreamt up by Tippett Studio. “They came to us as ‘Giant Droid A’ and ‘Giant Droid B,’’ reveals Daniel. “Us being the crew that we are, we’re like, ‘Well, we need to give them names.’ So, B became Bullethead for perhaps for the logically obvious reason to match his head shape. Then Mark named Arges after one of the three Greek cyclopees. And now that’s Star Wars canon.”
While the final result was incredibly pleasing to the Tippett Studio team, they are more than happy to share some war stories during the process. “There was a great shot where Arges falls to his knees,” recalls Gibbons. “Well, the armature was such that they could only bend forward at a 45 degree angle and then the whole thing locked up. So I basically had to suspend the rig and unscrew, at first, the toes, and then the heels of the feet and then through the armature that was exposed at that point, stick wires through those so that they wouldn’t slide around and drill two holes, stick the wires through to hold the ankle or the bottom of the shin to the floor and then take the feet in two pieces on each side and try to get them to look like they were folding under and going backwards. Big plastic metal parts couldn’t do that. So then I sculpted them out of clay and replaced the real ones with clay, bent them backwards and then put the real feet back in again. I challenge you to find that in the show! The only thing that I was missing was drawing a picture of a foot and sticking it back there.”
Gibbons also remembers a time when they were assembling Arges for a shot and forgot to add his side strap. “There’s this big leather plate that holds the straps together and somehow, it had gotten taken off so we could get to the armature. We just did a whole shot without it. Mark, being the art director, was beside himself. But I was like, ‘Yeah, nobody’s going to see it. It’s in the shadows.’ I actually can’t find the shot it’s missing in! I love little Easter eggs like that, like on the rare occasion where Harryhausen would leave a surface gauge in for one frame. It’s kinda nerdy fun to find little signs of the ‘hand behind the curtain’ on things like that.
Then there are the Easter eggs the team was able to include. Bullethead’s club that he swings as a weapon is one to look out for, suggests Daniel. “Mark made all these designs for the club, all of them really cool. And then for one of them was, he took a weapon from one of the original Star Wars Kenner action figures. It was the Lando Calrissian in Skiff Guard disguise. He had this little vibro-ax which Mark took and duplicated four times, and it was approved!”
“I just put it in there,” says Dubeau. “It was a stupid gag. If you look at the club and then you look at the vibro-ax, I just took the blade off the ax, then just put it around four times, and it’s almost completely unadulterated from the toy version. John Favreau was like, ‘I want that.’ I was really surprised. We called it the vibro-club.”
Another Easter egg relates to Bullethead’s belt buckle. For the Mama Crab we had little R2-D2s stuck in different areas,” mentions Dubeau. “Well, when we got Bullethead, he didn’t have a belt or anything like that. He just had a skirt that went around. And then as we progressed the design, they decided they wanted to have this rack of grenades on a belt. So, I designed a belt that worked a little bit like a conveyor belt. What I realized then was that we needed a belt buckle. Anybody who’s a big fan of Star Wars and pays attention to all the greebles that get put on a model ship, well, I chose something for the belt buckle, which is a very well known model piece used in a ton of stuff on Star Wars shows.”
“Hopefully, the fans that were watching it did one of those Leonardo DiCaprio point-at-the-screen memes when they saw it, because there’s this one shot where you see the grenade come around and he grabs it and the belt buckle is right there. I can’t do one of these projects without putting in a little Easter egg or two.”
All images © 2026 Lucasfilm Ltd
. All Rights Reserved.
The post Stop-motion delights appeared first on befores & afters.
来源:befores & afters · beforesandafters.com