《神奇动物在哪里》上映十周年:视效总监 Tim Burke 与 Christian Manz 回顾幕后
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them – 10 Years Later: Tim Burke & Christian Manz
《神奇动物在哪里》上映十周年之际,视效总监 Tim Burke 与 Christian Manz 重聚回顾该片视效制作。Manz 回忆 2015 年 1 月启动、长达八个月的筹备期,Stuart Craig 在 Leavesden 外景地搭建约九英亩的 1920 年代纽约四区街景。
Ten years after the release of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them , we reunite with Production VFX Supervisors Tim Burke and Christian Manz to revisit the film, reflect on their favorite memories, and look back at the visual effects that brought J.K. Rowling’s magical world to life.
Both supervisors originally spoke with The Art of VFX in 2016, and this anniversary retrospective brings their memories together a decade later.
The original interviews follows below, preceded by four new questions looking back on the film:
Ten years later, what are your strongest memories of working on Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them?
Tim Burke // Some of the best memories are from working on set with the actors, Eddie Redmayne and the rest of the cast were so enthusiastic, gracious and collaborative with their time and performances that it made the on set experience a joy, as it was with the rest of the crew and director David Yates. When you are making such a complex VFX film it’s vital that everyone from the crew to the actors embrace the project wholeheartedly, and this film was a great example of 100% collaboration between all involved. It was also a project which required the design and execution of numerous unique and original, never before seen creatures, which really is the dream job. We were given artistic freedom to run wild with our imagination in the designing and creation of said creatures, which made it so much fun!
Christian Manz // After a five year break from the Wizarding World, since completing Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part One, I started work on the film in early January 2015 – having interviewed with Director and Producer David Yates and David Heyman the previous November. Principal Photography commenced in mid August. The eight months of preproduction were some of the most creatively satisfying and fun times of my career to date. David Yates gave us the freedom to explore concepts and ideas, both in terms of the creature design and magical environments such as Newt’s case.
My Co Production VFX Supervisor, Tim Burke, was finishing work on Yates’s The Legend of Tarzan, and joined us full time for the shoot and post. Therefore in pre-production, Framestore Animation Supervisor Pablo Grillo and I created a visual development unit which was a mix of Framestore animators and concept artists, alongside previs teams from The Third Floor London, Nvizible and Proof. We had daily brainstorming sessions (often over lunch in the Leavesden Studios canteen) with Dermot Power, Rob Bliss and Paul Catling – who were working as concept artists for Stuart Craig in the Art Department – and presented our ideas together to the Davids and Stuart in a gallery like space we created, where we could put everything on the walls in story order. This was a collage of everything from sketches on large post-it notes, to fully worked up art – all supported by animation studies, previs and Dermot’s visual development renders of the sets. And those sets were amazing – Stuart created about nine acres representing four districts of nineteen twenties New York on the Leavesden backlot, as well as multiple large scale builds in sound stages. It was really immersive for cast and crew alike.
In post production, the collaboration continued as Tim, Pablo and I worked with a more than fifty person in house team – made up of Framestore animators, The Third Floor London, Nvizible, Proof, Double Negative previs as well as freelance compositors and matte painters – to create postvis for the director’s cut. It really was amazing to work with everyone in one room, sharing ideas and assets, with the singular aim of helping to tell the story in the best way possible, with much more freedom than you can in final VFX. We used several companies, alongside Framestore to create the final work – Double Negative, Rodeo FX, Image Engine, MPC, Method and Cinesite and Milk – and for me, it was the start of collaborations and friendships which have continued into future projects.
I have a great memory of sitting in the bar at BAFTA in London with Pablo, having presented the film for a screening. We heard the end title music and the doors of the theatre opening and realised how long we’d been chatting. People came up to us and said how much they’d enjoyed it and loved the VFX. It was so nice after twenty one months of hard work to get that feedback from our peers!

Looking back at the film today, which VFX sequence or creature are you still most proud of?
Tim Burke // The erumpent was great, working with Eddie on set with a giant full sized puppet of the erumpent at night was very memorable, and the development of the erumpents’ character and behaviour was challenging and fun. However the Obscurus was probably the hardest character to execute and the one we really had to evolve during the post production process, and ultimately the scenes involving it were the most rewarding, if very difficult. From the huge action sequences on our Times Square set to the more emotive, nuanced performances in the subway, it was incredibly challenging to create emotion from something that looked like a mass of swirling tar, but we managed it.
Christian Manz // That would have to the Newt’s Case sequence. It was a labour of love from the start of preproduction until final delivery and involved the collaboration of a lot of departments on the physical production and VFX, in prep and post. The scene was made up of several very long shots designed in nine months of previs with Proof. When it came to the final shots, some had five companies working on them – Framestore, Double Negative, Rodeo FX, Image Engine, MPC and Method. It was a technical and creative jigsaw and it was the final VFX delivery day before I could show David Yates one of the shots in all of its glory, with all of the elements put together, rather than as individual vignettes. Rodeo FX in particular, under the supervision of Arnaud Brisebois, had some really heavy lifting to do, and weathered some last minute changes, but delivered fantastic work.
Rewatching it today, for the first time in ten years, I can see there are definitely places where we could have done better. But the sequence exemplifies everything I love about VFX at it’s best – the collaboration of a lot of talented people coming together to create a unique, detailed magical environment inhabited by a myriad of creatures, that the audience would hopefully find something new in, every time they watched it.
Another favourite is film’s climax. Newt releases Frank, the Thunderbird, into the sky above New York, creating a rain storm that wipes the muggle citizen’s memories of the magical events that have hit the city. Complex creature animation, effects and environment work from Double Negative and Framestore, combined with James Newton Howard’s soaring score, really helped pack an emotional punch.

How differently would you approach the visual effects of Fantastic Beasts if you were making the film today?
Tim Burke // I probably wouldn’t change the approach at all. I think the whole process of pre-vis and character development in advance of shoot is essential, followed by the use of simple proxies for each creature operated on-set by puppeteers, or using a stand in/stunt actor in grey suit, gives the actors and director something solid and real to work with. Then a period of detailed post-vis on the editors rough assembly, using animators from the facilities to block and develop performance of all of the creatures, allows both editor and director to find their cut, as well as helping us finalise character development. This linear approach makes the final post production process more streamlined and efficient, it doesn’t prevent changes later, as their are always unwanted surprises further down the line, but it does help focus the decision making early on in post. Maybe I’m a bit old school, but 40 years in the industry has taught me to keep things as simple as you can for everyone, sometimes unnecessary technology can over complicate things.
Christian Manz // The way I approach projects today is based, in a lot of ways, on what I learned on the first Fantastic Beasts film. I have a strong belief that the best VFX work results from a lot of planning and collaboration. This includes doing a lot of previs, design and animation in prep to guide the shoot, and then postvis to inform the cut.
Over the course of the three Fantastic Beasts films, and now on How To Train Your Dragon, I’ve been pushing to see that as much of the work that is done in early pre production, makes it through to the final shots. Back then we’d previs with one group of artists, postvis with another set and then finish the work with other studios entirely. By Fantastic Beasts – The Secrets of Dumbledore, each of the final VFX vendors did their own postvis, and we only had one previs vendor. This meant that each team could take more creative and technical ownership of their sequences, and we were much more efficient – throwing away less work. A lot of the reason why a project such as How To Train Your Dragon is bugetarily feasible in today’s environment, is the flow of work from concept, visual development, previs, and postvis into the final shots.
Another area where we could have done better was digital environments. To create our New York set extensions we, of course, had Stuart Craig’s amazing sets to LIDAR and texture capture. We also went to the city to recce and take lots of reference photographs. We didn’t do any LIDAR scanning though, or photogrammetry. That made hitting the final shot finish more difficult than it should have been. Reference is everything in creating any CG elements and we were doing a lot of guess work. On every film since we have done large scale location capture and plate photography, which has enabled look development of the environments to start on a much sounder footing. By the third Fantastic Beasts film we were capturing large chunks of period Berlin buildings as well as large scale photogrammetry of mountains in Switzerland, and helicopter film plates.
I have worked with Dominic Ridley and Clear Angle Studios on every one of my projects since their inception. Their innovation and ambition in what and how they approach capture has always impressed me and meant that, hopefully, we’re giving the VFX teams the best data we can, to start their work.

From the beasts of Fantastic Beasts to the underwater world of The Little Mermaid (and How to Train Your Dragon for Christian), how has your approach to creating believable creatures evolved over the past ten years?
Tim Burke // For the last 24 years I have been independently supervising films for production, which has allowed me to work with many facilities all over the world. During this time facility pipelines have been constantly evolving, making the creation of photo-realistic creatures easier now than ever before, some facilities have moved faster than others, some have stagnated and some sadly aren’t around anymore. On Beasts our creatures were fantastical, but their behaviours were all taken from observations of real-world animals, sometimes taking the traits of more than one species and blending them to make something unique. I think it’s vitally important to ground any creature in reality, and the best way to do this is to create behaviour which is recognisable and relatable. We can only do this through the skills of brilliant animators and animation directors. What is also vitally important is the successful integration of their performance into a scene, achieved by using onset proxies or stand in actors which the director can direct and the real actors can work off, which also allows the camera department to compose shots without compromise, treating them as you would any actor. These principles have been important in my work since the early Harry Potter days and remain as true now as ever before.
What I really loved about The Little Mermaid was the time and importance Rob Marshall gave to rehearsals; it was such a complicated shoot because of the numerous talking CG creatures and having all the actors performing in movement rigs, but because we rehearsed each scene thoroughly in advance, when we came to the actual shoot, we were efficient, hitting schedules without compromise, whilst also giving the director the time to focus on getting great performances from the actors, without being frustrated by things not working. We also pre-recorded and filmed with witness cameras, all of the actors playing the talking CG characters, which allowed the editor to cut scenes with the proper dialogue and turn over facial actor reference for the animators to work from. We were obviously not copying the facial performance literally but it helped develop each of the creatures characters and personalities by referencing the real actors’ gestures, intonations and expressions. Combined with the observation of real world animals for physical performance, this helped create successful and believable characters, which the audience could relate to and empathise with.
Christian Manz // All creature concept and development was run by us in the VFX department. We’d of course ask Stuart Craig for his notes and guidance, as well as presenting to Davids Yates and Heyman, but it made much more sense to evolve the designs of the Beasts in concept alongside animation in VFX. Design and character work in tandem. On current projects we push this stage further visual development wise, using software like Blender to produce more photographic representations of the creatures, which we can use to get filmmaker and studio sign off so that the full asset work can start as early as pre-production. We didn’t do that on Fantastic Beasts, and therefore we were getting asset design notes deep into post, which wasn’t optimal.
The use of puppets on set was one of our biggest innovations. We were the first to do it, employing the team from the National Theatre production of War Horse, and this has become an important methodology all of my jobs since. As it was a new thing for everyone, including the actors, and if I had my time again, I would have been bolder with leaving them in shot and made sure the actors interacted with them during takes, rather than miming. There are some some shots that make me cringe today because of the lack of believable connection between human and digital Beast. Though the paint out can be challenging, the bond between Mason Thames and Tom Wiltons puppet on set completely sell the relationship between Hiccup and Toothless in the raw dailies.
And, of course, in the last decade, the fidelity in detail of both the animation, build, rigging, simulation and shading involved in delivering final creature work has grown more and more advanced with every year. Fantastic Beasts had lots of challenges from the feathered Niffler (always my favourite) through to the glowing Qillin in the final film. The dragons we are now realising though are even more challenging because of how close we get to them for sustained periods of time in shots, and with no fur, there’s no where to hide with the muscle, fat and skin simulations. Definitely something we wouldn’t have been able to do in so many shots ten years ago.
The creation of the Niffler taught me a lot, especially watching Pablo crafting an animated performance that had no dialogue, but was charming and funny. Observing how David Yates worked with actors, keeping an understated reality in their performances, was also something I was privileged to experience in the my eight years of working closely with him on those three films.
Creature work has been a big part of nearly every project I have led in the last twenty years. In that time Framestore has really become the industry leader in delivering nuanced characters which have delivered performances which have struck a chord with cinema audiences. Knowing the amount of work that goes into every frame of this type of work, at lots of VFX companies – every tiny animation note that is addressed, every hair that is groomed to perfection, every bit of lighting finessed – even with the advent of gen AI, I personally feel the craft involved in VFX Creature work will continue to be huge and exciting challenge for VFX artists for years to come.

//// The original interview below was published in December 2016 ////
Christian Manz — Read the original 2016 interview
Tim Burke — Original interview published on November 16th, 2016 (below)
Tim Burke is working in the visual effects for the past thirty years. He won an Oscar for the Best VFX for GLADIATOR. He supervised the VFX of 7 of the 8 Harry Potter movie. After a trip in the jungle with LEGEND OF TARZAN, he is back in the Harry Potter universe with FANTASTIC BEASTS AND WHERE TO FIND THEM.
What was your feeling to be back in the Harry Potter universe?
I was very happy to be back in the world of JKRs magical imagination, but it felt quite different working on BEASTS to the previous HARRY POTTER films, it’s a very different film altogether, set in a much earlier period, 1926 New York, with completely different actors, without the familiar faces of Dan, Emma and Rupert. It was an exciting new challenge.
How was this new collaboration with director David Yates?
Working with David doesn’t really change, he is incredibly collaborative, he lets us all contribute to the making of the film in so many different ways that its always a great joy. We had a great creative input in designing the creatures and the big action set pieces.

How did you split the work with VFX Supervisor Christian Manz?
We worked on the film together until the script settled down and we could start to decide which facilities would be working on which characters and sequences. As much as possible we wanted to try to not overlap supervising with the facilities, and tried to split the work up so that the film was evenly spread across several companies, with each of us looking after those particular vendors. We had realised early on that on top of all of the many creatures and sets to be built there were two very large areas of work, newts case, it’s environment and creatures, and the Obscurus and it’s environments and massive destruction sequences. So we split those two things between us, Christian handled the Case and I did the Obscurus, after that we split the work evenly so that creatures and their environment were paired together.
How did you use your experience on the Harry Potter movies for Fantastic Beasts?
Generally the working methodologies were similar, techniques we’d used to film magic sequences were re-utilised, using interactive practical effects and lights where relevant. We revamped a lot of the magic effects for BEASTS but still referenced the HP films for their style.

Have you changed some of your methodology?
The biggest change would be the way we postvized the whole movie with our in-house team, in fact the whole first assembly of the film at over 3 hours.
Can you tell us more about the previs and postviz process?
We started previs in early pre production building a large team of artist from The Third Floor, Nvizage and Proof, supplemented by half a dozen animators hand picked by Pablo Grillo, our in house animation director. We designed set piece sequences incorporating the animation and character studies of each of the creatures that our creature concept team had been doing. Previz was used on set as a guide for puppeteers and actors a like, we shot every scene faithfully matching the previz in most instances.
We kept our team of artist on during the start of filming then expanded them into an even larger team, adding a tracking and compositing department, with two DMP artists and a few additional modellers. We effectively made a small facility of about 50 artists, who worked for about 6 months from the middle of the shoot up until the delivery of the directors cut to the studio, and we postvized every creature and environment into every shot, so that David could show the studio a complete representation of how the film was going to play.
This also then allowed him to adjust his edit, get the timing of actions sequences working and see what each of the creatures brought to the film, where they worked and where scenes needed developing further in post.

Can you describe to us one of your typical day during the post?
As we supervised postviz during our production days, post really started mid shoot, arriving on set at 7:30, preparing for the days shoot, and the first set up, then racing back to discuss the days work with the various artists, we had two edit suites running as well. We’d spend most of the day on set then catch up again with previz at the end of the day on wrap.
We moved to Soho when filming was over and spent more time with our in-house previz team and our external facilities. We were working across three time zones so the day was structured around cineSyncs and vendor visits in London.

It’s a show full of magical creatures. What was your approach about it?
We wanted the creatures to have magical properties, but not be too fantastical, we designed them so that they were similar to real world animals but different in certain ways, so that they felt ground and real. It was very important that they didn’t become too extreme and unbelievable.

How did you with the director and the art department for the creatures design?
We ran the concept and animation department and developed the creature designs, we’d show David Yates designs on a daily basis, take his notes and develop the creatures further or disregard initial sketches he did think worked. We designed hundreds of different creatures to varying levels of completion.
Which one was the most complicated to created and why?
The Obscurus was the trickiest creature because it was hard to pin down exactly what it was, a repressed malevolent force of evil without form. We went through many different concepts and designs, at one point actually creating a beast which we blocked into shots in Times square, then realised that it was incorrect to have the Obscurus as an actual creature. We settled on a shape shifting membranous twisting black mass, which had to take on different characteristics and personalities which could express emotions, anger, rage, sadness.
Double Negative who did the work, came up with a simple animation system of shapes we could animate in Maya, then use to drive the simulations and FX. However it was hard for the director to understand what was happening until he saw the FX rendered, so the process itself was time consuming and difficult. We couldn’t even start the destruction effects until we’d locked the animation and effects of the Obscurus itself, so it made things very complicated.

How did you simulated their presence on-set and their interactions with the cast?
We had the props department make simple puppets for each of the main creatures, these were then operated by actual pupeteers, led by Robin Guiver. We had the team who played the horse in the stage production of warhorse be our Erumpent, operating a 17ft tall, 20ft long carbon fibre frame. This really helped Eddie and the other actors understand what the creature was doing and where it was. We’d shoot a few rehearsals with the puppet in, then shoot clean after the actors and camera operator got used to the performance.

And which creature is your favorite one?
Probably the Demiguise, because he has a lovely innocence about him.

Which sequence was the most complicated to created and why?
It would have to be the Obscurus scenes for all of the previous reasons I’ve mentioned.
Can you tell us more about the New York creation?
We recced in New York and Stuart Craig noted details of buildings and architectural styles that he wanted to recreate. He then went about designing an 8 acre set on the backlot which was on a grid street layout like New York, but each block was a different stye of architecture, representing a different area of new York we’d use in the film. There were Tenements, Brownstones, The Diamond District (Tribeca) and 5th Avenue. We covered up the architecture we weren’t using in green cloth and still utilised the roads and pavements for traffic. We shot with crowds of up to 300 and 40 practical period vehicles. The actors were primarily shot on the practical area of set and then we extended the streets in each direction with the matching digital architecture for that area. We did an extensive 2 month stills shoot of textures and buildings in New York to generate the library of buildings we’d need.

How did you work with the stunt and special effects teams to enhance their work?
It was a good collaboration between each department, stunts often provided wire rig performances which we’d clean up and augment if necessary. SFX provided lots of on set practical FX, steam, smoke, wind, rain, snow etc and we’d compliment and add to that with digital FX in the extensions. We also shot lots of hi-speed reference of breaking materials on the Phantom as reference for destruction sequences and the scenes where things magically rebuilt themselves.
Is there any invisible effect you want to reveal to us?
Hopefully the biggest invisible effect is New York itself, given we never actually shot there, and all of the exterior sequences you see in the film were actually shot on the back lot at Leavesden and Cardington.
How have you choose the various vendors?
As always we played on the different facilities strengths, keeping character animation with companies we knew were experienced and capable, the FX work with other facilities and the environment work with companies we had great faith could recreate photographically realistic and good work.

How did you split the work amongst these vendors?
Basically on their strengths, trying not to overload one particular vendor with too much work
Was there a shot or a sequence that prevented you from sleep?
Once again I have to say it was the Obscurus.
What do you keep from this experience?
It was a great fun film to work on and be creatively involved with, I hope there will be many more like it to follow.
How long have you worked on this show?
19 months.
What’s the VFX shots count?
1’500.
What was the size of your team?
The core production team was 12 people, then we had our previz/postviz teams which grew to 50 people at it’s maximum.
What is your next project?
It will be the second BEASTS film starting in January.
A big thanks for your time.
© Vincent Frei – The Art of VFX – 2016
来源:The Art of VFX · artofvfx.com